What Was Won and Lost in Dubai
After India’s convincing win over Pakistan in cricket in
Dubai yesterday , The Indian Express today carried the front-page headline “ India
wins hands down over Pak, skip the handshake: For Kin of Pahalgam victims,
Armed Forces “ The sports correspondent’s report
mentions that at the end of the game the Indian captain walked away
without shaking hands with Pakistani players or their captain . Obviously, one
cannot shake hand with one’s hands down!
Yes, the mood of the team and that of most in the country is that this cricket win is the
true decider of Operation Sindoor against Pakistani terrorists, which after
four days of hostilities ended with both armies agreeing to a ceasefire ,
notwithstanding President Trump’s
repeated claim that he brokered this ceasefire.
The question arises why the
winning in a sporting event should be considered
to decide the winner in the case of conflicts between nations over issues like
terrorist attacks, border disputes, etc,.
The Government of India and the
BCCI were not against India playing
Pakistan in Dubai; only a faction of a regional political party and some
members of the victim of Pahalgam massacre protested against the match.
Even after a major shift in India’s
relations with Pakistan marked by
significant tension and hostility after Pahalgam, the diplomatic relations between
the two countries have only resulted in a
limited presence of staff in their
respective embassies and not a total abandonment
There is a famous saying that the Battle of Waterloo was won on
the playing fields of Eton, implying that the discipline, leadership, and
values earned by British officers in public schools like Eton provided the
foundation for their victory in the Napoleonic wars.
With reference to sports, it may be said that apart from the above
qualities, a team’s respect for the
overall aim and purpose of sports and
observance of courtesy and etiquette on the field is as important if not more than winning.
Nations use sports and sportsmen as ambassadors to promote
goodwill and friendship . This alone represents the spirit of playing the games and the reason why the late Jawaharlal
Nehru exhorted the sportsmen to play the game in the spirit of the game.
Before the advent of ODI and T20 formats cricket
matches were of 5 days duration
and called TEST Matches as they were
considered the ultimate test of a cricketer’s skill, endurance and temperament. Implied were also the players’ gestures of
friendship, empathy and mutual respect. Cricket was called a Gentlemen’s
game for features like accepting the
Umpires’ decision as final, a dress code of white flannel for players and some
rare cases of foul language. A shining
example of concern and extraordinary
empathy was that exhibited by the West
Indies captain Sir Frank Worrel and his team mates when the Indian cricket captain Nari Contractor sustained
a severe head injury while facing a bouncer from Charlie Griffith in 1962 .
In the past, India’s win over Pakistan in cricket were
celebrations merely as a sports victory and not for any other reason.